Buttery Nipple Shot Recipe

The Buttery Nipple Shot is a particularly fine dessert shot. So sweet and smooth and creamy you will be completely satisfied. A nice shot of sweet satisfaction.

A buttery nipple shot is a cream based shot that uses Butterscotch Schnapps. The base of this shot is two ingredients Bailey’s Irish Cream and Butterscotch Schnapps. This shot gets its name from the creamy buttery taste of the butterscotch. It’s a delicious and easy shot to take.

This shot is also known in different forms by other names like cowboy…and a few names I’m not saying here. They are not exactly the same recipe. But they DO use the same ingredients.

The cowboy is double the alcohol. I like the buttery nipple as a mellow sweet creamy shot.

Check out ALL of our delicious alcohol drinks in our Cocktail Section. We have a little something in there for everyone who drinks.

What Alcohol is in Butterscotch Schnapps?

Butterscotch schnapps is a liqueur. Schnapps is made from flavoring, sugars, and a base spirit. The base spirit for butterscotch schnapps is commonly Jamaican rum. Butterscotch schnapps is very smooth and has a lower ABV (alcohol by volume). The ABV of most butterscotch schnapps is between 15-20%. This is an easy schnapps to drink, and is popular in fall and winter cocktails.

What drinks can you make with butterscotch schnapps?

The buttery nipple is probably the most popular butterscotch schnapps drink However, it certainly isn’t the only delicious beverage you can make with it. Here are a few of our favorite drinks to make with butterscotch schnapps:

1. Buttered Monkey Cocktail
2. Butterfinger Milkshake (alcohol version)
3. Caramel Apple bomb shot
4. Butter Beer (alcohol version)
5. Banana Foster Cocktail
6. Butterball Cocktail
7. Butter shots Cocktail
8. Candy Corn Martini
9. Slippery Nipple
10. Salted Caramel White Russian
11. Butterfinger Cocktail
12. Butterscotch Coffee Cocktail
13. Buttery Hot Chocolate
14. Butterscotch Martini
15. Butterball Shots

Shots that are creamy:

• B-52 Layered Cream Shot
• Blow Job Shot
• Butterball Shooter
• Cinnamon Toast Crunch Shot
• Scooby Snack Shot
• Irish Slammer (bomb shot)
• Oatmeal Cookie Shot
• Nutty Irishman
• Candy Corn Pudding Shots
• Mudslide Shot
• Nutella Vodka Shots
• Baileys Butterfinger Shots

Buttery Nipple Recipe:

Have a butterscotch shot for a lovely after dinner drink or drink with a friend.

At 129 calories per shot The Buttery Nipple is a great choice for a dessert drink. It’s sweet and tasty. And Way less calories than a chocolate martini, espresso martini or baileys mudslide or holy cow the Banana Split dessert Cocktail.

Buttery Nipple Ingredients:

This is SO simple to make. Who doesn’t have a bottle Baileys Irish Cream and Butterscotch Schnapps in the ole wet bar? You don’t? Go get them. You will find lots of drink recipes to use them up. Promise.

This shot is 32 proof or about 16% alcohol. Perfect relaxer but not too powerful. Just right. Enjoy!

Garnish:

I make the buttery nipple in a tall 2 oz. shot glass so I have room to add a dollop of whipped cream on top. That just finishes this drink perfectly as a dessert drink.

You can also add a fresh raspberry on top if you like. It’s tasty and adds a certain…ambience. If you take my meaning.

More Delicious Shots:

Your Printable Recipe Card:

If you print this recipe card the pictures will not print. This is to save you paper and ink.

For more information on this recipe please also watch our recipe demonstration video at the bottom of this recipe card.